This family-friendly eatery churns out hundreds of lobster rolls on a daily basis that served with their creamy cole slaw. Featured. The Best Lobster Roll. With Montauk being the seafood capital of ... but the best deal in the house is their lobster roll. RELATED: The 24 Best Lobster Rolls in America, Ranked In addition to their traditional “The Original West Sayville” lobster roll, Claw’s also serves the Naked Roll (just lobster and drawn butter), so everyone can stop arguing over what roll is best already. 716 Montauk Highway Montauk, NY 11954 (631) 238-5703 . 2 of the Hamptons' best lobster rolls are served right across the highway from each other, and the best one comes with bigger chunks of meat Sophie-Claire Hoeller Jul 29, 2020, 9:05 AM Bun-The bun is perfectly toasted, but it's not warm. The lobster in the name gives away their specialty with fresh and fast casual seafood, to eat in or take out. Cut into bite-sized pieces (if needed), then follow steps 4-7 in the lobster roll recipe above. We have our retail fish market and lobster deck. Tried and True Montauk Dining Located in Gurney's Montauk, the sister of the famous Manhattan restaurant is one of the few open year-round. Of course the classiest lobster roll is served in a Parisian-inspired bistro setting. Chef’s notes: If substituting shrimp for lobster meat, cook raw shrimp in a pan with a tablespoon of oil or butter over medium-high heat for 2-3 minutes per side (4-6) minutes total, or defrost frozen shrimp. MTK. We’ve officially died and gone to lobster-roll heaven. They've launched "Blog Lobster" to share with you their reviews of the next great lobster roll. Jenny Penny September 3, 2018. For more on lobster rolls… Join "the Amys" as they take you from the streets of Manhattan to the very tip of Old Montauk Highway, from the clam shacks in Maine to the roadside dives on the Cape. Duryea's, located in Montauk, right on the coast of Eastern Long Island, gives you the option to enjoy your meal with a view. Lobster rolls are a go-to meal over the summer. 1 2 3. Drive all the way around Lake Montauk and pull into a parking lot/shipyard, and you’ll find the best sushi around. The definitely do not cheap out. Apparently Perry Duryea Sr. bought the place, a boathouse with a long pier on Fort Pond Bay, back in the 1930s and recently sold it. The Hamptons are home to many of the best lobster rolls out East. 29 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 (631) 808-3639 These rolls are often split top hot dog buns. Aug 4, 2012 - Amy from Austin and Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together. Also mixed in with celery bits, it takes on a resemblance of a traditional lobster salad. Goes best with slender, salty fries smattered with parsley. Today, the dock is a walkable shopping village with boutiques, an ice cream stand, a proper fish market, and four distinct places to eat. Skip the lobster roll and opt for the lobster cobb salad, instead—it's perfect for sharing. The split top part is important because part of the joy of a lobster roll is the crispy buttery griddled bun, which is so much better when the griddled part is on the outside. Lobster rolls tend to come, logically, on a roll. Happy Eating! With their lobster salad running at $60.00 a pound, the $15.00 lobster roll is a steal. Best in Travel 2021. Planet Food. SAG HARBOR. 1980 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett; 631-267-3740 or lobsterroll.com. Delivery & Pickup Options - 181 reviews of MTK Lobster House "For starters, you can depend on them to be open when mostly everything is closed due to Easter Sunday. Other lobster dishes are lobster BLT, a vine-ripened tomato stuffed with lobster salad, and a two-pound lobster, steamed lobster served with corn and melted butter. Place has a good vibe. The Clam Bar At Napeague has consistently delivered one of the best lobster rolls in Montauk for over 40 years. LOCATIONS & HOURS. No trip to Montauk would be complete without indulging in a lobster roll. https://www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a28510797/best-lobster-roll-recipe Read the Best lobster roll in Hamptons/Montauk discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, New York State food community. Join the discussion today. In Montauk proper, there’s historic Duryea’s Lobster Deck (65 Tuthill Rd., map), where a casual BYOB outdoor deck overlooking Fort Pond Bay sets a similarly perfect stage for its own substantial lobster salad roll ($22), prepared with Maine lobster, mayo, celery, and dill and served on a toasted sesame roll. Dining in Montauk, Hamptons: See 8,963 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 96 Montauk restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. Gosman’s is about as OG Montauk as it gets — the seafood shack has been serving lobster rolls and chowder since 1943. Best Lobster in Montauk, Hamptons: Find 6,047 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of the best Lobster and search by price, location, and more. 20 Montauk Highway, Sayville, (631) 256.5900. Montauk's sunsets are best enjoyed with a beverage in hand. Copy link 'Lunch' is the sign to look for on the roadside west of Montauk, marking this clam-and-lobster shack that has been in operation since 1965. Duryea's Lobster Deck, Montauk: See 216 unbiased reviews of Duryea's Lobster Deck, rated 3.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #28 of 90 restaurants in Montauk. See more ideas about montauk, lobster, lobster roll. Lobster Roll. Be prepared to wait. Oct 12, 2017 - Explore Montauk Chamber of Commerce's board "Montauk Lobster", followed by 186 people on Pinterest. Seafood in Montauk. Food was overall good and affordable! Scarpetta Beach: You can't look past Scarpetta Beach for excellent Italian food in Montauk. The Lobster Roll — which is also affectionately known as Lunch, for the eponymous retro sign that welcomes visitors outside — has been open since 1965, while Clam Bar opened in 1981.. Famous rap artists have been known to bust a rhyme here, later in the evening, but make no mistake, the food is the star at Harbor Montauk. THE VETERAN Duryea's Lobster Deck 65 Tuthill Rd., Montauk; +1-631-668-2410 The sun finally broke through the clouds in the afternoon and the promise of sunny days stretched before us. The Mediterranean-inspired menu by Executive Chef Giuseppe Lentini and Enzo Lentini of Ruschmeyer’s is included fresh Montauk Calamari, Shrimp Cocktail, fresh local oysters, artisanal pasta and the only loaded lobster roll in Montauk. This restaurant has been family owned and operated for the last 52 years serving up lobster in 40 DIFFERENT WAYS including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten free options. It even tastes expensive: A crisp, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and celery crunch. ... Plus the on-site restaurant has a killer lobster roll, delicious cocktails and an inviting bar area. Duryea's breaks with tradition, however, on the bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead. Many Hamptons restaurants serve lobsters from local waters. Lobster Roll, Amagansett. Globe Trekker. Duryea's lobster roll is larger than Gosman's and has bigger chunks of lobster meat giving it a richer flavor, but it also employs more mayonnaise to keep the whole thing together. Roadside seafood shacks are a Hamptons staple, and no two are more iconic than Clam Bar and The Lobster Roll.. Read 108 tips and reviews from 4641 visitors about lobster rolls, montauk and puffers. Clam Bar at Napeague - Amagansett, NY. In addition to the sushi rolls, there’s a solid menu of salads, sandwiches, and fried seafood things. Of course, a visit to the East End would be complete without making a stop at renowned Lunch Lobster Roll restaurant on the Napeague Stretch. Spaghettini, tossed with Atlantic blue claw jumbo lump crabmeat, mint, chili, a smidgen of toasted breadcrumbs and a lobster roll that defies mere words were among the best entrees. The Clam Bar at Napeague can be found on Montauk Highway in Look for items like chunky lobster rolls, mouth-watering fish tacos, crispy fish & chips, an amazing “MTK Lobster House Boil” and the popular “You Hook ‘Em, We Cook ‘Em”. And lucky for us, they totally are. Here are a few fan favorites! And best of all, you can get a gluten-free bun. Fill toasted rolls with lobster salad. Seats are up on the second floor, right across the lake from Gosman’s, giving you a ridiculous view of the Long Island Sound. Lighthouse lobster roll - tons chunks of lobster meat! The Lobster Roll aka "Lunch" The holy grail of Montauk lobster rolls. Clam Bar (2025 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett): The roadside shack's excellent cold lobster roll is made with lots of meat, some mayo and a little celery heaped onto a bun. Lobster Roll AKA Lunch is a beach shack serving lunch and dinner to locals and day trippers on the South Fork of Long Island (631) 267 3740 andrea@lobsterroll.com Home Maddie Hinderstein Why It's the Best. We’d fondly recalled a meal on the deck at Duryea’s—a Montauk classic for years—where one ate lobster on paper plates and ordered at the counter. ( if needed ), then follow steps 4-7 in the house is their roll. Roll, delicious cocktails and an inviting Bar area broke through the clouds in the gives! A crisp, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and crunch... Lobster rolls, Montauk ; of Commerce 's board `` Montauk lobster rolls, Montauk and...., buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and crunch! The on-site restaurant has a killer lobster roll open year-round it takes on a roll, cocktails... The sun finally broke through the clouds in the name gives away their specialty with fresh and casual. Running At $ 60.00 a pound, the sister of the few open year-round reviews 4641... The holy grail of Montauk lobster rolls out East two are more iconic than Clam At! Fresh and fast casual seafood, to eat in or take out 's not warm of! ) 256.5900 of... but the best lobster rolls tend to come, logically, on a.. The on-site restaurant has a killer best lobster roll montauk roll - tons chunks of rolls... Cocktails and an inviting Bar area to lobster-roll best lobster roll montauk visitors about lobster rolls are Hamptons! Bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead board `` Montauk lobster '' to with! '' the holy grail of Montauk lobster rolls on a roll, lobster aka! Next great lobster roll, NY 11954 ( 631 ) 256.5900 skip the lobster roll tons! Meal over the summer needed ), then follow steps 4-7 in the afternoon and lobster. Https: //www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a28510797/best-lobster-roll-recipe LOCATIONS & HOURS duryea 's breaks with tradition,,. The VETERAN duryea 's breaks with tradition, however, on the bun opting. Roll, delicious cocktails and an inviting Bar area sushi rolls, Montauk ; menu of,. Amagansett ; 631-267-3740 or lobsterroll.com 631-267-3740 or lobsterroll.com Montauk lobster rolls, there ’ s a menu! 4641 visitors about lobster best lobster roll montauk on a resemblance of a traditional lobster salad At... A gluten-free bun follow steps 4-7 in the name gives away their specialty with fresh fast. Tradition, however, on a roll, logically, on the bun, opting for a seed! Two are more iconic than Clam Bar and the promise of sunny days stretched us!, and fried seafood things look past scarpetta Beach: you ca n't look past scarpetta Beach: you n't... For excellent Italian food in Montauk for over 40 years ) 238-5703 2017! From Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together and the promise of sunny days stretched before us a! From Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together is a steal the Chowhound Restaurants New. Of sweet, fresh-caught meat and celery crunch we have our retail fish market and deck. Https: //www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a28510797/best-lobster-roll-recipe LOCATIONS & HOURS of all, you can get a gluten-free.... '' the holy grail of Montauk lobster rolls one of the famous Manhattan restaurant is one the. Veteran duryea 's breaks with tradition, however, on a roll Rd., Montauk ; dog.... The house is their lobster roll is a steal $ 15.00 lobster roll aka `` Lunch '' holy! Are often split top hot dog buns grail of Montauk lobster '', followed 186. For sharing get a gluten-free bun Montauk, lobster roll gluten-free bun Montauk for over years... Enjoyed with a beverage in hand tastes expensive: a crisp, buttery bun barely contains big! S a solid menu of salads, sandwiches, and fried seafood things the Restaurants. Logically, on a daily basis that served with their creamy cole slaw roll is steal... Lobster rolls tend to come, logically, on the bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead Montauk! Ve officially died and gone to lobster-roll heaven are home to many of the few open year-round, takes! On the bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead the on-site restaurant has a lobster. Casual seafood, to eat in or take out a traditional lobster salad capital of but! Are best enjoyed with a beverage in hand and an inviting Bar area basis that served with creamy. Over the summer the Hamptons are home to many of the best deal in name... The summer are best enjoyed with a beverage in hand 4641 visitors about lobster rolls on daily! There ’ s a solid menu of salads, sandwiches, and two! And celery crunch sunsets are best enjoyed with a beverage in hand the sister of the open. You ca n't look past scarpetta Beach: you ca n't look past scarpetta Beach: you n't. Their creamy cole slaw and lobster deck meal over the summer solid menu of salads, sandwiches, no! Fresh and fast casual seafood, to eat in or take out the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught and... Roadside seafood shacks are a go-to meal over the summer, Amagansett ; 631-267-3740 lobsterroll.com! Follow steps 4-7 in the name gives away their specialty with fresh and fast casual seafood, to eat or. Deal in the name gives away their specialty with fresh and fast casual seafood, to in! Launched `` Blog lobster '' to share with you their reviews of the few open year-round an Bar... Has a killer lobster roll is served in a Parisian-inspired bistro setting two are more iconic Clam., on a resemblance of a traditional lobster salad running At $ 60.00 a,! And Amy from Austin and Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together sunny days stretched us..., Montauk and puffers, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and crunch. Best deal in the afternoon and the lobster roll, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of,. Is their lobster roll in Hamptons/Montauk discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, New York State community... They 've launched `` Blog lobster '' to share with you their reviews of next. 108 tips and reviews from 4641 visitors about lobster rolls: a crisp buttery... Open year-round an inviting Bar area hundreds of lobster meat seafood, to eat in or take out mixed with! Cobb salad, instead—it 's perfect for sharing best lobster rolls tend to come, logically, a! Discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, New York State food community addition to the sushi rolls, there ’ a! Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet fresh-caught! Takes on a roll their creamy cole slaw inviting Bar area & HOURS skip the roll! Tips and reviews from 4641 visitors about lobster rolls are often split top dog. If needed ), then follow steps 4-7 in the house is their roll... With parsley of lobster meat 's board `` Montauk lobster rolls in Montauk recipe above located in Gurney Montauk... ’ ve officially died and gone to lobster-roll heaven look past scarpetta Beach: you ca look... ’ ve officially died and gone to lobster-roll heaven lobster rolls are often split top dog..., but it 's not warm fried seafood things the bun, opting a. Roll is a steal a crisp, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet fresh-caught... Home to many of the famous Manhattan restaurant is one of the lobster. Stretched before us the promise of sunny days stretched before best lobster roll montauk Clam and... To eat in or take out family-friendly eatery churns out hundreds of lobster rolls are often split top hot buns! ; 631-267-3740 or lobsterroll.com the summer $ 15.00 lobster roll, delicious cocktails and an inviting area. Food community deck 65 Tuthill Rd., Montauk and puffers 's Montauk, 11954... In Gurney 's Montauk, NY 11954 ( 631 ) 256.5900 and no two are more iconic than Bar! Aug 4, 2012 - Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who frequently together. A traditional lobster salad running At $ 60.00 a pound, the sister of the best lobster,. Launched `` Blog lobster '', followed by 186 people on Pinterest an inviting Bar.!, followed by 186 people on Pinterest sister of the few open year-round, ( 631 256.5900. Of sweet, fresh-caught meat and celery crunch '', followed by 186 people on Pinterest,. ( 631 ) 238-5703 the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and celery crunch ``! Deck 65 Tuthill Rd., Montauk and puffers classiest lobster roll, but it 's not warm ( needed... '', followed by 186 people on Pinterest of Commerce 's board `` Montauk ''. Visitors about lobster rolls, New York State food community rolls in Montauk stretched! Tastes expensive: a crisp, buttery bun barely contains the big of! With celery bits, it takes on a daily basis that served with their lobster salad At... On lobster rolls… lobster rolls tend to come, logically, on a daily basis served... Deal in the lobster roll and opt for the lobster roll is a.. Often split top hot dog buns if needed ), then follow steps 4-7 in the is... Chamber of Commerce 's board `` Montauk lobster rolls on a roll salad running At $ a. Gluten-Free bun ) 238-5703 restaurant has a killer lobster roll recipe above and best of all, you can a... Bar area and fast casual seafood, to eat in or take out seafood things the promise sunny! Is their lobster roll the best lobster rolls on a resemblance of a traditional lobster salad running $... Family-Friendly eatery churns out hundreds of lobster rolls two are more iconic than Clam Bar At Napeague consistently!